Can mental illness be a valid defense in criminal charges?

Schedule a Free Consultation

 Posted on September 26, 2024 in Uncategorized

# Can mental illness be a valid defense in criminal charges? | The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart

![Image 1: The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart](https://www.michaelaustinstewart.com/)

Does Your Situation Call For A Hero?

Call Us Today: [253-948-3586](tel:+1-253-948-3586)

Text Us Today:[253-442-7544](sms:+12534427544)

![Image 2: The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart](https://www.michaelaustinstewart.com/)

You Need A Hero

[CALL](tel:+1-253-948-3586)

[Text](sms:+12534427544)

Your Freedom, Your Reputation, Our Mission

  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Criminal Defense
  4. »
  5. Can mental illness be a valid defense in criminal charges?

# Can mental illness be a valid defense in criminal charges?

On Behalf of The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart](https://www.michaelaustinstewart.com/ "Posts On Behalf of The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart") | Sep 26, 2024 | [Criminal Defense

When facing criminal charges, defendants may wonder whether mental illness can be a valid defense. Mental health issues can play a significant role in criminal cases, but the success of this defense depends on specific factors and legal standards.

Understanding mental illness defenses

There are two common mental health defenses: insanity and diminished capacity. The insanity defense argues that the defendant was unable to understand the nature of the crime due to a severe mental disorder. Diminished capacity, on the other hand, seeks to show that the defendant’s mental illness impaired their ability to form intent, which is required for most criminal charges.

Legal criteria for an insanity defense

To succeed with an insanity defense, the defendant must meet the legal criteria, which vary by state. Generally, the defense must prove that the mental illness was severe enough to prevent the defendant from understanding their actions were wrong. Psychiatric evaluations are usually required.

Challenges in using mental illness as a defense

Mental illness defenses can be challenging to prove. Not all mental health conditions qualify for a defense, and courts may require substantial evidence linking the illness to the criminal behavior. Additionally, juries may be hesitant to accept this defense unless there is overwhelming proof.

Alternative outcomes

Even if mental illness does not result in an acquittal, it may lead to reduced charges or lighter sentencing. Defendants may also receive mental health treatment as part of their sentence, particularly if they can show their condition contributed to the crime.

Mental illness can be a valid defense in most cases if evidence exists to meet the above requirements, but it requires strong legal strategy and evidence that will be compelling to a jury.

Search for:

Search for:

Recent Posts

Archives

Categories

RSS Feed

Subscribe To This Blog’s Feed

Get Your Life Back On Track With Our Help

Loading Form...

Contact Us

![Image 3: The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart](https://www.michaelaustinstewart.com/)

Address:

1105 Tacoma Ave South

Suite A

Tacoma, WA 98402

Tacoma Office

Call Us Today:

[253-948-3586](tel:+1-253-948-3586)

Text Us Today:

[253-442-7544](sms:+12534427544)

Review Us

![Image 4](https://www.michaelaustinstewart.com/tacoma-criminal-defense-law-office/)

You need a respected and aggressive criminal defense attorney on your side. We will fight to protect your future.

© 2026 The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart • All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer| Site Map| Privacy Policy |Business Development Solutions by FindLaw

!Image 5: fb

╳

!Image 6

How can I help you?

!Image 7!Image 8

How can I help you?

How can I help you?

Welcome to The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart. What kind of matter can we assist you with?

How can I help you?

!Image 9: Intaker widget Avatar

Felony

Misdemeanor

Sex Crimes

Theft

Drug Charges

DUI Defense

Other Criminal Cases

Scroll

Powered byIntaker

Share this post:
As Seen On
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge
  • badge

The first few hours after an arrest can be incredibly stressful, but they may also be incredibly important for your case. Anything you say during questioning could be used against you in court, even if police appear sympathetic to your circumstances. During this time, protecting your rights is absolutely critical. If you have been accused of a crime, do not hesitate to get in contact with a skilled criminal defense lawyer who can advise you on how to respond.

Attorney Michael Austin Stewart has decades of experience representing clients throughout Pierce County and the South Puget Sound in serious felony cases. When you work with our firm, your case will receive close attention from a seasoned trial attorney who will explore all of your options to fight the charges in court.

Proven experience representing clients in high-stakes criminal matters

When your freedom, reputation, or career is at risk, you need a respected and aggressive criminal defense attorney on your side. Attorney Michael Austin Stewart's successful case results speak to his diligence and willingness to fully investigate a charge. Across his 30-year career, he has obtained favorable outcomes for many clients, routinely securing sentencing terms well below the government's request as well as dismissals and not guilty verdicts.

Past case results are not a guarantee of future outcomes. Instead, they show the lengths we are willing to go to protect our clients. You only get one chance to protect your freedom and your name in a criminal case, so you should not settle for anything less than the best when looking for the right attorney.

scales

Case Results

Our firm has a demonstrated history of successes in criminal defense cases, frequently securing ideal outcomes through our fierce advocacy.

Felony DUI Dismissed

Achieved after court found no probable cause for the traffic stop

Felony Domestic Charges Dismissed

Secured after further investigation revealed death threats were falsified

Firearm Charge Dismissed

Achieved after it was revealed that the officer conducted a warrantless search without reasonable suspicion

Not Guilty Verdict in Rape Case

Defendant was completely exonerated after extensive cross-examination and arguments from defense

More Case Results

Reputable criminal defense trusted by local communities

Attorney Michael Austin Stewart has a reputation for being extremely tough in the courtroom while being approachable and personable with his clients. His main goal is to set you at ease while providing aggressive representation in court, taking a stand to protect your rights. We are available 24/7, as we remain in close communication with our clients in every case.

Our firm has also been recognized with many awards for our excellent client service and strong representation. Some of these accolades include placement in the Top 100 Trial Lawyers by The National Trial Lawyers, recognition as a Super Lawyer, and a 10.0 Avvo rating. We have also earned many 5-star reviews from clients we have personally helped through difficult situations, highlighting the trust we have built up across Tacoma and the wider community.

Strong counsel when you need it most

You can trust our firm to handle your case with the tact and care that it deserves. We know how to manage the media in cases that garner public attention—having taken on cases featured in CBS, The Washington Times, The Seattle Times, and other outlets—working to protect our clients' privacy as we build a careful defense. We also know how to navigate communication with police and prosecutors to minimize any possible risks.

arrowExplore more services
The Law Office of Michael Austin Stewart Criminal Defense Lawyer

Focused on
the Best Case
Outcome

Whether you are facing property crime charges, allegations of violent crime, or sex crime accusations, our firm will seek the best possible outcome to your case. To accomplish this, we carry out in-depth investigations to uncover all of the relevant facts, allowing us to build a nuanced argument to present to the court. Attorney Michael Austin Stewart is a trial-tested criminal defense lawyer with the skills and legal knowledge to present a strong case on your behalf.

If you have any questions about how we can help with your situation, do not hesitate to reach out. Seeking early legal counsel is critical for making sure that you are fairly represented during the criminal proceedings.

arrSchedule a Free Consultation
scales

Verdict Spotlight

Felony DUI Dismissed

Achieved after court found no probable cause for the traffic stop

Felony Domestic Charges Dismissed

Secured after further investigation revealed death threats were falsified

Firearm Charge Dismissed

Achieved after it was revealed that the officer conducted a warrantless search without reasonable suspicion

Not Guilty Verdict in Rape Case

Defendant was completely exonerated after extensive cross-examination and arguments from defense

See More Verdicts

Award-Winning

Our firm has been honored with many awards for our exceptional criminal defense.

30+ Years of Experience

Attorney Michal Austin Stewart has decades of courtroom experience defending clients accused of felony crimes.

Free Consultations

We offer free consultations to any prospective clients with questions about a pending criminal case or investigation.